Reply To: What are the top Alternative Fusion candidates?

[kingkong]

Aha, by simulation …! Even worse, an extrapolation of simulation results!
No real experiment or measurement at all ???
As well known in the art, the result of a simulation fully depends on the skill
as well as the sense of responsibility of the person who conducts the simulation.
Therefore my question: is the paper cited above already published in a refereed
journal? I understand very well, publication in a refereed journal is not a guarantee
of acceptance or correctness. But if it fails to get published, it really means something,
i.e., it is incredible. Why? Most probably because it contains a lot of mistakes, either
mathematical or conceptual, most probably both. As to the sense of responsibility,
if a person is possessed by greed either for money or for fame, or both, the result
of his simulation would rather reflect his own wishful thinking, rather than the truth.
So, the paper you showed me does not lend any credibility at all. Sorry ….
😉 🙄 :bug: